Close

Click Where You Would Like to Share this Page

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google Plus Email
Canine Lifetime Health Project Logo
  • Donate
Menu
  • About Us
    • About
    • Morris Animal Foundation Website
    • Registration: Dog Lovers
    • Registration: Veterinarian
  • Golden Retriever Lifetime Study
    • About
    • Study Participants
    • Study Veterinarians
    • Study Volunteers
  • News
    • Recent Stories
    • eUpdate
  • Resources
    • FAQs
    • Study Participant Resources
    • Study Veterinarian Resources
    • Study Volunteer Resources
    • Materials Request
    • Contact Us
  • Ways to Donate
    • Make a donation
    • Send a tribute card
    • Start your own campaign
    • Donate by mail
  • Story Categories

    • All
    • Canine Health
    • Events
    • General Interest
    • Study Participant News
    • Veterinarian


Interested in joining a nationwide effort to create a healthier tomorrow for dogs?

Join our Canine Lifetime Health Project registry of dedicated veterinarians and dog lovers of all breeds for potential inclusion in future studies.

To Register:

Veterinarians >
Dog Lovers >

Already Registered?

Login >

OK, I’ve got the data…now what?

  • General Interest
July 15th, 2015
Share Story Facebook Twitter

Last month, Dr. Missy Simpson answered a few questions about her new role as epidemiologist for Morris Animal Foundation’s Golden Retriever Lifetime Study. This month she answers a couple questions about interpreting data gathered from big studies.

How do you figure out what is significant and what isn’t when you have thousands of data points? What is the most common mistake made when analyzing big data sets?

It is easy to think that the more data you gather, the better. While this is true to some extent, there are pitfalls that are unique to big data sets. The most common errors relate to making associations. Big data contains a lot of information and it is tempting to just look at everything for a potential association. This can result in two problems: finding associations that really don’t mean anything clinically, and finding associations that are due to chance.

Let me give an example of the first problem:

Suppose we conduct two studies looking at two treatments for separation anxiety in dogs. One study wants to learn if increasing exercise an extra 20 minutes a day reduces anxiety. This study has 30 dogs in it. The second study wants to test the effectiveness of an expensive anti-anxiety medication. This study has 5,000 dogs in it. Suppose both reduce anxiety by 300 percent. Statistically, the expensive drug is looks better, reflecting the large number of dogs in the study.

Which treatment would you use on your own dog to treat separation anxiety? I think most of us would choose exercising our dogs for 20 minutes rather than buying an expensive drug. Although on paper the bigger study looks better, clinically the smaller study results are more useful.

This example simplifies things a bit, but reminds us that we need to be careful in interpreting what is clinically or practically significant when we have a big study.

The second problem with big studies is how we interpret things that might happen by chance. We know coincidences happen all the time. When we have really big studies, it is easier to find these coincidental associations, and if we aren’t careful, we can interpret these findings as significant associations instead of recognizing that they are just chance occurrences. There are precautions epidemiologists take to avoid making this error, but it still happens.

A big study like the Golden Retriever Lifetime Study is great because if we do our statistical analyses carefully, when we find an association we can be confident it is significant. We just need to be careful not to succumb to the temptation to over-interpret our data set.

  • Previous Story
  • Next Story
Morris Animal Foundation
  • Calendar >
Join Us
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram Pinterest
Golden Retreiveer Lifetime Study Partners
  • Partners
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
© Copyright 2018 Morris Animal Foundation
720 S. Colorado Blvd., Suite 174A, Denver, CO 80246 | 855.447.3647